Difference between revisions of "Feedback from Barry Ritchie/ Tue Apr 14"

From GlueXWiki
Jump to: navigation, search
Line 4: Line 4:
 
#* Suggests that Section 5.2 -> Subsection 5.1.1
 
#* Suggests that Section 5.2 -> Subsection 5.1.1
 
#* Add a final subsection summarizing on each background with a conclusion/summary
 
#* Add a final subsection summarizing on each background with a conclusion/summary
# Incoherent backgrounds. Needs work.
+
# Incoherent backgrounds.  
#* Need to simulate eta->3pi and Npipi backgrounds
+
#* Need quantitative estimates
 
# Other backgrounds
 
# Other backgrounds
#* Also needs some quantitative numbers
+
#* Need to simulate eta->3pi and Npipi backgrounds
 
# Suggests that we add a final section simulating all backgrounds together to demonstrate effective extraction of the signal
 
# Suggests that we add a final section simulating all backgrounds together to demonstrate effective extraction of the signal
  

Revision as of 09:47, 17 April 2020

Barry setup a zoom meeting this noon to give me some feedback on the NPP proposal. He has read the proposal and said that it is generally in good shape, but has comments on the section on backgrounds. He had the following comments:

  1. Introductory points on backgrounds are clear and lay a good foundation
  2. Coherent backgrounds. This is section is nicely worked out.
    • Suggests that Section 5.2 -> Subsection 5.1.1
    • Add a final subsection summarizing on each background with a conclusion/summary
  3. Incoherent backgrounds.
    • Need quantitative estimates
  4. Other backgrounds
    • Need to simulate eta->3pi and Npipi backgrounds
  5. Suggests that we add a final section simulating all backgrounds together to demonstrate effective extraction of the signal

A final comment was a question we should include any discussion on a lead-tungsten calorimeter (immediately before 5.4.2).

  • He will be glad to give us comments on the background section when it has been updated.
  • Also at that time he will provide suggestions for wording and clarifications in the text